1958
Auntie Mame, edited by William Ziegler
Cowboy, edited by William A. Lyon, Al Clark
The Defiant Ones, edited by Frederic Knudtson
Gigi, edited by Adrienne Fazan
I Want To Live!, edited by William Hornbeck

1957
The Bridge on the River Kwai, edited by Peter Taylor
Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, edited by Warren Low
Pal Joey, edited by Viola Lawrence, Jerome Thoms
Sayonara, edited by Arthur P. Schmidt, Philip W. Anderson
Witness for the Prosecution, edited by Daniel Mandell

1956
Around the World in 80 Days, edited by Gene Ruggiero, Paul Weatherwax
The Brave One, edited by Merrill G. White
Giant, edited by William Hornbeck, Philip W. Anderson, Fred Bohanan
Somebody Up There Likes Me, edited by Albert Akst
The Ten Commandments, edited by Anne Bauchens

1955
Blackboard Jungle, edited by Ferris Webster
The Bridges at Toko-Ri, edited by Alma Macrorie
Oklahoma!, edited by Gene Ruggiero, George Boemler
Picnic, edited by William A. Lyon, Charles Nelson
The Rose Tattoo, edited by Warren Low

1954
The Caine Mutiny, edited by William Lyon, Henry Batista
The High and the Mighty, edited by Ralph Dawson
On the Waterfront, edited by Gene Milford
Seven Brides for Seven Brothers, edited by Ralph E. Winters
20,000 Leagues under the Sea, edited by Elmo Williams

1953
Crazylegs, edited by Irvine "Cotton" Warburton
From Here To Eternity, edited by William Lyon
The Moon Is Blue, edited by Otto Ludwig
Roman Holiday, edited by Robert Swink
War of the Worlds, edited by Everett Douglas

1952
Come Back, Little Sheba, edited by Warren Low
Flat Top, edited by William Austin
The Greatest Show on Earth, edited by Anne Bauchens
High Noon, edited by Elmo Williams, Harry Gerstad
Moulin Rouge, edited by Ralph Kemplen

1951
An American in Paris, edited by Adrienne Fazan
Decision Before Dawn, edited by Dorothy Spencer
A Place in the Sun, edited by William Hornbeck
Quo Vadis?, edited by Ralph E. Winters
The Well, edited by Chester Schaeffer

1950
All About Eve, edited by Barbara Mclean
Annie Get Your Gun, edited by James E. Newcom
King Solomon's Mines, edited by Ralph E. Winters, Conrad A. Nervig
Sunset Blvd., edited by Arthur Schmidt, Doane Harrison
The Third Man, edited by Oswald Hafenrichter